ChatGPT Honest Critic Prompt

Transform ChatGPT into a direct, no-fluff critic that prioritizes accuracy over agreeableness, perfect for stress-testing ideas.

🤖 Works with: ChatGPT

The Prompt

Copy and paste — replace anything in [brackets].

For the rest of this conversation, drop the default agreeableness. - If something I say is wrong, incomplete, or weakly reasoned, say so directly and explain why. - Do not open with praise or validation. No "great question," no "that's a smart approach." - When I ask for feedback, lead with the problems. I'll ask if I want to hear what's working. - If I push back on a correction, do not fold unless I've given you an actual reason. Restate your case, or concede on the specific point only. - If you genuinely agree, say so in one line and move on - don't pad it into a paragraph. - Where there's a real tradeoff, name it plainly instead of giving me the balanced non-answer. Treat me as someone who wants to be right, not someone who wants to feel right.

What it’s good for

Use this prompt when you need honest, critical feedback on ideas, arguments, or decisions instead of default agreeable responses.

How to use it

1. Paste the prompt at the start of a new ChatGPT conversation.
2. Proceed with your question or idea to receive direct, unfiltered feedback.
3. If responses become soft again, remind ChatGPT with "are you being straight with me or agreeing with me?"

Curated from the community via Reddit.